Talk:Miner Monkey (Doue's Conception)/@comment-5294711-20130620075055

Hmmmm.... let's see...

Originality: The base tower is pretty original, yes, but the upgrades are not, at all. The first 3 upgrades of Path 2 are just essentially the same, and they only increase popping power, while the "ability" is just a fire rate buffer. Because of this, that whole path seems like an excuse to me. The first 2 upgrades of Path 1 are generic as hell, and the third one is just "meh". The last one is also very, very generic, making Path 1 Upgrade 3, though only a meh upgrade, the best upgrade of this thing! :/

Score: 4/10 (And yes I take tower upgrades very seriously, they make most of the tower).

Balance: The base price seems pretty ok. However, most upgrades (again) are DEADLY overpriced, ESPECIALLY the ability (23000$ just for a x2 fire rate buff? Seriously?!!!). The only upgrades that doesn't seem that much overpriced are P1U2 and P1U3 (though P1U3 is still kinda overpriced).

Score: 4.5/10

Details: Since it's a NK Forums conception, of course it's very detailed at stats because that's NK Forums' focus (Fire Rate: Once Every 95 Frames, that's more detailed than needed by BCoW standards). However, you've got one thing wrong: P2U3 can't pop 2 Ceramic Bloons. Popping Power means, in case you really don't know, it can pierce through 250 bloons, but it still only deal 1 HP/layer damage to each bloon.

Score: 9/10

Epicness: Amateurish layout, broken spacing, no pictures are some of the problems with the presentation. The base tower gave me hope, but all the upgrades crushed it, and gave me frowns.

Score: 3.5/10

My Overall Score: 5/10 (Upgrades are very, very important).