Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5294711-20150731173229

Calling all the official critics (if you are a critic please tell me, even I've lost track of things these days... :S). So as you can see, currently our assessment scheme is a bit boring, thus I'm here to make a small proposal to spice things up. It mainly deals with how you can put your review scores on a conception's page, as well as rewards for certain conceptions based on review scores.

First, I think we (the official critics) should all use an unified rating system. Personally, I propose using my own, since that's the one you should be most familiar with.

Secondly, about how to put your review score on the page. Well, first, you should create an Official Ratings section on the conception page if you're planning to post your ratings. Then, that section will be divided into two smaller ones: the Review Scores section and the Awards section. The Review Scores section should have a table like this:

While the Awards section will hold the awards that conception has gotten (including tournament awards), along with the username of the critic that gave that award. A short reason of why that award was given is also encouraged, but not compulsory.

Thirdly, about the awards themselves, I haven't designed any award pics yet, but you can use your own version of the award pics if you like. Meanwhile, I'll work with Mr.OAH to design some "default" award pics. The (review-score-based) awards are:


 * Shining Conception: Overall score of 8 or above.


 * Legendary Conception: Overall score of 9 or above.


 * Godly Conception: All scores except Originality of 10, Originality score of 8 or above.


 * Ultimatum: Overall score of 10.


 * Fantasia: Overall score of 11.


 * Out of the Box: Originality score of 8 or above.


 * Game Changer: Originality score of 9 or above.


 * Unfathomable: Originality score of 10.


 * Lightbulb on Head: An exceptionally creative point is present in the conception, regardless of the overall Originality score.


 * Yin-Yang: Balance score of 9 or above.


 * Libra's Blessing: Balance score of 10.


 * Documentary: Details score of 9 or above.


 * Deep Research: Details score of 10.


 * Grandiose: Epicness score of 9 or above.


 * Adrenaline: Epicness score of 10.


 * Minor Setback: Overall score of 8 or above WITH a component score of below 5.


 * Cherry on Top: Total extra points (from good art, self-composed soundtrack, etc.) of +1 or above.

That's the end of my proposal for today. What do you think about the awards? If you have any comments, or extra award ideas you'd like to add, please tell me in the thread. You can also propose to use another rating system if you want. Ok then, thank you for reading this and supporting the wiki!

Koufuku Metanana 17:32, July 31, 2015 (UTC) 