User blog:Meta07/New Rating Criterias



Today I have some things to add to our rating system! We've all been familiar with Originality, Balance and Details (and the bonus points category Graphics), but today I think we should add another criteria:

Epicness
I've always tried to group "Epicness" score together with the "Originality" score, but now I think I should make it a whole other criteria. Why? Because a conception may not really be that "creative" in its technical sense, but it's so cool people must say "wow" when they read it and it becomes famous or vice versa, a conception maybe creative, but it's poorly done that it still bores some people and doesn't have much impact (looks at GLaDOSPortal).

Anyway, that's it. This criteria is to gauge the amount of impact that conception had to the critic, as well as the amount of effort put into the development of the conception! Epicness is x1 like Balance and Details.

Series Rating
If many conceptions are made together as parts of a series, I think apart from the rating for individual parts, we should have a general rating for the whole series too (i.e. Score for "E.N.T.I.T.Y.": x/10, Score for "Reactor Core" series: y/10...)! Ehh... that's it, I guess...? :/