Talk:Monkey Guardian/@comment-4650748-20150726235517

NOT AN OFFICIAL CRITIC (How do you become one anyway?)

Detail: 9/10

You've given a lot of facts here, although what's the size of it? Also, I like range in pixels.

Balance: 5/10

Cost: 4000 Range: 150 HP: 50 Shield strength: 10 ALGO: (Range x (HP X Shield strength))/Cost (150 X (50 X 10))/4000 = (150 X 500)/4000 = 75000/4000 = 18.75

COMPARISON

Super monkey: Algo: Cost: 3500 Range: 250 HP: 40 Attack Rate: 17.24 Popping power: 1 (250 x (40 x (17.24 x 1)))/3500= (250 X (40 X 17.24))/3500= (250 X 689.6)/3500= 172,400/3500 = 49.257 Quite underpowered compared to the Super Monkey, which costs less

Creativity: 8/10

There is quite a lot of creativity here, although generating a shield is what it really does(until you get upgrades)

Likelihood of implementation: 4/10

I'm sorry, I doubt Ninjakiwi would implement this. There's the main reason of it being based on the health system, but all of the conceptions use that so I omit it. Despite this omission I still doubt Ninjakiwi would implement something like this, despite its creativity.

OVERALL: 26/40(6.5/10)

Rating: This is pretty good! Well done!