Board Thread:Campaigns and Tournaments/@comment-5294711-20140208133022

Well, as another proposal for the Resurrection project, I think it'd be a good idea if you form an official Critics team which will try to give "official" ratings to as many conceptions as possible. These ratings can be used for many things in the future, including ratings-based event, but most importantly, it'll be used for my second point, the Individual Conceptions' Merits.

So far, you already have merits (userboxes) for users, so why not make merits/medals for individual conceptions too? Just the Conception Tournament trophies is not enough, since they are so rare, and they are only given after a looong period of time. Here are my current proposals for Conceptions' Merits:

Level 1 Merits

 * Thinking Outside the Box: Get an Originality score of 8 or more from a critic


 * Yin Yang: Get a Balance score of 10 from a critic


 * Encyclopedic: Get a Details score of 10 from a critic


 * Epic: Get an Epicness score of 9 or more from a critic

*Famous: Get 50 comments that are not spam

*Eye Candy: Has a picture so good it gives you a +0.5 score from a critic

Level 2 Merits

 * Breaking the Barriers: Get an Originality score of 9 or more from a critic


 * Celestial: Get an Epicness score of 10 from a critic


 * Critically Acclaimed: Get acclaimed by a critic (average score of 8 or more)


 * Thinking Outside the Box II: Get an Originality score of 8 or more from 3 critics


 * Yin Yang II: Same as above, but with Balance score of 10

*Encyclopedic II

*Epic II

*Super Star: Get 100 comments that are not spam


 * Work of Art: Has a picture so good it's got a +1 bonus from a critic


 * Defining: Has at least 10 conceptions that used a system/mechanic introduced in this conception

Level 3 Merits

 * Wondrous: Get an average score of 9 or more from a critic, and every criteria must have a score of 8 or higher

*The Odd One Out: Basically "Breaking the Barriers II"


 * Up to the Heavens: Basically "Celestial II"


 * Recommended by Critics: Basically "Critically Acclaimed II"

*BCoW Icon: Has at least 200 comments that are not spam

Level 4 Merits
*Monumental: Basically "Wondrous II"

*Cornerstone: Has at least 50 conceptions that used a system/mechanic introduced in this conception 