Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5294711-20150731173229/@comment-5294711-20150804234856

Geez, you guys think too technically.

By "inconsistencies" I mean, for example, Critic A uses only the three base criteria, while Critic B uses five criteria, and Critic C also uses five criteria but the "extra" 2 criteria are different from Critic B's. Then, the average score for Critic A will go something like this: (Orig*2 + Balance + Detail)/4 (Originality takes 50% of score), Critic B and C will be more like this: (Orig*2 + Balance + Detail + Something + Something)/6 (Originality takes 33% of score), and that "something" won't even be the same for every critic.

That way, is the overall score from Critic A the same as that from Critic B and C? I don't think so...